About a year ago, Congress finally caught up the work they had postponed while campaigning and extended the estate tax deductions which had expired and reverted to 2001 levels. The new law gave each taxpayer a $5 million dollar exclusion (exemption) before the estate tax would kick in. If the deceased estate was under $5 million, they don’t have to file an estate tax return. More than $5 million and the tax is figured on the difference. (Ok, estate and gift taxes are very complicated subjects and so please check with your tax professional. This post is for general info.)
Actually, the law gave $5 million exclusion to each person but $10 million to a married couple. The difference is portability. Joe and Mary are married. In 2011, Joe passes away with only a $1 million estate. He still has $4 million of his exclusion left. In 2012, Mary dies but her estate is $7 million. So, she uses her $5 million exclusion and files a Form 706 (Estate Tax Return) to pay the tax on the remaining $2 million – right? No, since Joe still had $4 million of his exclusion, Mary can use that in addition to her $5 million. She has a total potential exclusion of $9 million. That’s why the exclusion for a married couple is $10 million. The first taxpayer to die can use up to $5 million and the second to die gets what ever is left or $5 million, whichever is higher.
But – for portability to work there has to be a Form 706 filed for the 1st taxpayer that dies. According to the current instructions for the 706, part 4 line 4, “the executor is considered to have elected to allow the surviving spouse to use the decedent’s unused exclusion amount by filing a timely and complete Form 706.” The Form 706 has to be filed even if the taxpayer would not be required to file it otherwise to preserve portability.
How does a surviving spouse, or their preparer, know when to file a protective portability claim? Well, it might be a good idea to do it every time. In the Joe and Mary example, Joe wasn’t required to file a Form 706. If it wasn’t filed, Mary would have only received her $5 million exclusion. But it would have been clear from looking at Mary’s assets that there was a good chance she would need the extra exclusion. But what about Ken and Barbie who together only have their house, a couple of cars and a few thousand in the bank? If Barbie dies, there would not be any reason to file an estate tax return. But if one isn’t filed, then Ken will only get a $5 million exclusion. He wouldn’t even need that unless there was a major change in his assets after Barbie died. But if he wins a $20 million lottery before he dies, his estate would really like the extra exclusion
This could have a major impact for tax professionals. If Ken and Barbie are my clients and I don’t offer to file the protective Form 706, I would be at risk for Ken’s estate to file a malpractice suit against me. I cost it the tax on an extra $5 million. It doesn’t have to be a lottery win. The surviving spouse could receive an inheritance, a court settlement or have surprise assets that could use the higher exclusion.
I first read about this issue earlier this week and made a note to check into it. But Professor Roger McEowen director of the Center for Agriculture Law and Taxation at Iowa State University presented the Estate Tax section at the Kansas Tax Institute and stressed this issue. His suggestion was file a Form 706 to preserve the portability for everyone. If the surviving spouse doesn’t want to do that, have them sign a release stating that it’s their decision not to file Form 706.
A quick review, the estate tax portability issue only applies to married couples. And it will only apply if both taxpayers die in 2011 or 2012 (the current estate tax extension is only good until Dec. 31, 2012) unless Congress keeps the rule when they deal with estate tax next year. But to protect the surviving spouse, an estate tax return (Form 706) should be filed for the first taxpayer to pass away. Then the second spouse retains the extra exclusion just in case they die while portability is in effect.